The Virginal Three- Waters (VT) 1931 Flanders L
[Below are Coffin's introductory notes from Flanders' Ancient Ballads. This ballad covers over 80 pages, the most extensive collection published. I had trouble understanding Flanders notes about Waters and her mother and the sailor-- anyway-- Waters "remembered these stanzas from The Virginal Three from a sailor named, Hugh singing to her mother, Mrs. Emma Robinson Titus" but "Titus had learned them when a child of five." Just another of life's little mysteries. I guess my point is the ballad is much older than 1931. How much older? When Mrs. Titus was five.
R. Matteson 2014]
The Sweet Trinity or the Golden Vanity
(Child 286)
This ballad is immensely popular in America and not hard to find in Britain. It dates back to a broadside of the 1680's in which the deceitful captain is Sir Walter Raleigh. (See Flanders FF.) Since then it has taken many forms and may conclude in any number of ways. The Flanders texts give an excellent cross section of the plot variations found in this ballad. In A-T the boy drowns in the lowlands low. In U, he sinks the captain's ship as well as that of the enemy before he drowns. In V, he also sinks the captain's ship and there is only one survivor to tell the tale. In W, he sinks the captain's ship, ironically drowning the girl he loved with the crew. In X, he dies after being hauled on deck. In EE his ghost returns to treat the captain to a glass of beer before sinking the boat. In FF-JJ, the heroic lad is rewarded with a leave of absence, the daughter's hand, or gold and silver. Of these texts, A1, with the stanzas on the phantom ship, and R, with the lines borrowed from "The Mermaid" (Child 289) are noteworthy. So are V, with its one survivor, like Melville's Ishmael; and FF, which preserves the name of Raleigh, if not the ending, from Child A" The vessel's name, originally The Sweet Trinity, varies greatly in America, becoming The Golden Vanity, The Green Willow Tree, The Merry Golden Tree, and so on. Its opponent, sunk by the cabin boy, was "a false galley" in the old broadside, but it is more likely a Turkish (or Russian, Irish, French, etc.) Revelee or "Shavaree" (sloop) in the States.
There is a certain preposterous quality to this song, and college students and music hall writers have exploited this fact in a series of parodies. see Coffin, 155, for references. Perhaps for the same reason, it has been extremely popular with sailors.
A long bibliography for "The Sweet Trinity" is easy to come by. See coffin, 153-5 (American); Dean-Smith, 69; Belden, 97 (English); Greig and Keith, 228-9, and Ord, 450-1 (Scottish). Phillips Barry, British Ballad's from Maine, 339-47, includes and discusses it. There is a song, once in a while confused with "The Sweet Trinity," called "The Low-lands Low." while it has a similar burden, it tells a very different story and goes back to an English stall ballad, "Young Edwin in the Lowlands Low" (Laws M 34), that was well known here and in Britain, see Laws, ABBB, 197-8; Belden, 127; and Dean-smith, 118, for some references to it.
The tunes for Child 286 can be divided into six groups which, however, may turn out to be related at least to some extent. The groupings are as follows: (1) Davis, Edwards, Moses, Burditt, and possibly Pease; (2) George, Daniels, Houghton; (3) Henry, Blake, George, Barry; (4) Clarke, Cassidy, Richards, Dragon; (5) Ingalls; and (6) Fish and Percival. The Ingalls runs seems to be a version of the popular "Canada-I-O." In order to save repetition, the tune relationships for standard collections are given here. Only relatively close tunes have been selected. from the large number available. In spite of their profusion, however, there is a lack of analogues for groups (2) and (6). For group (3), see Sharp I, 282-285, 2B9 I; FCB 4, 120, 47 A, 121 A (I), 123 C (I) ; BES, 346, ROI, 195, 200 (D); BI, 160. For group (3), especially the Blake rune, see BES, 34b (distant). For group (4) see Sharp l, 287, 288 G; GCM, 214; ROI, 200.
L. "The Virginal Three" Mrs. Frederick Waters of Brattleboro, Vermont, remembered these stanzas from "The Virginal Three" from a sailor "named, Hugh" singing to her mother, Mrs. Emma Robinson Titus of Burliigton, Vermont. Mrs. Titus had learned them when a child of five, living in Barton, Vermont. H. H. F., Collector; July 12, 1931.
The Virginal Three
The captain he ordered his ship to sea,
Sailing in lowlands low,
The captain he ordered his ship to sea
And the name of it was The Virginal Three,
Sailing in the Lowlands, low, low, low,
Sailing in the Lowlands low.
(Follow pattern of first stanza for all stanzas.)
We had sailed but a night or two
When a Turkish galley hove up in view,
(Captain asked who will go and destroy it.)
Then speaks up this little cabin boy,
"Oh, what will you give me if the ship I'll destroy?"
"Oh, it's I'll give you gold and I'll give you fee
And when we get home, to my daughter married be."
(Boy takes tools and "He stuck three holes in one.")
He folded his arms across his breast
And away he swam to the captain and the rest.
(He gets there and the captain refuses to take him on board.)
"If it were not for the honor of your men. . ."
(Cabin boy says he'd take his tools and serve him the same.)
"I'd serve you the same."
(Mr. Bigelow, 13 Green Street, also knew this song and thought in the full version of this ballad the cabin boy was saved in some strange way and got home and married the captain's daughter.)