All The Pretty Little Horses- Shirley Lomax Mansel

All The Pretty Little Horses
Shirley Lomax Mansell- 1939

All The Pretty Little Horses

Traditional Old-Time Bluegrass Lullaby


Painting by Richard L. Matteson Jr. C 2006
 

ARTIST: Shirley Lomax Mansell

Listen: http://memory.loc.gov/afc/afcss39/263/2638b1.mp3

Listen: Richard L. Matteson C 2009. Lyrics 2006. All The Pretty Little Horses MP3
Demo recorded & arranged by Richard L. Matteson Jr (guitar) with his niece Kara (vocal) Dec. 2009.

CATEGORY: Southern Recording Trip- Lomax 1939 

EARLIEST DATE: Civil War period printed in 1925, 1926, 1927 (Sandburg) and 1934.

Dorothy Scarborough, "On the Trail of Negro Folk Songs," 1925 (1963 reprint by Folklore Associates, pp. 144-149.

Carl Sandburg, The American Songbag (1927). Sandburg, pp. 454-455, "Go To Sleepy" (1 text, 1 tune, in which the child is promised rewards upon waking -- but seemingly also threatened with the "booger man" if it won't sleep)

John A. Lomax and Alan Lomax, American Ballads and Folk Songs (1934). Lomax-ABFS, pp. 304-305, "All the Pretty Little Horses" (1 text, 1 tune)

RECORDING INFO: All the Pretty Little Horses

Rt - Rocky Bye Baby; Go to Sleep/Sleepy Little Baby (Bye); Mama's Gonna Buy
Lomax, J. A. & A. Lomax / American Ballads and Folk Songs, MacMillan, Bk (1934), p304
Scott, John Anthony (ed.) / Ballad of America, Grosset & Dunlap, Bk (1967), p204 (Hushabye)
Lomax, John A. & Alan Lomax / Folk Song USA, Signet, Sof (1966/1947), # 2
Winds of the People, Sing Out, Sof (1982), p 57 (Pretty Horses)
Blood, Peter; and Annie Patterson (eds.) / Rise Up Singing, Sing Out, Sof (1992/1989), p130
Fox, Lillian M. / Folk Songs of the United States, Calif. State Series, Sof (1951), p41
Silverman, Jerry / Folksingers Guide to Note Reading and Music Theory, Oak, Sof (1966), p39b,p53
Mursell, James, et.al.(eds.) / Music Now and Long Ago, Silver Burdette, Bk (1956), p101
Archer, Frances; and Beverly Gile. International Songs and Ballads, Stand 408, LP (196?), trk# A.01
Chasman, Paul. Solo Guitar, Rose, LP (1978), trk# B.04
Deller, Alfred. Western Wind, Vanguard SRV 73005, LP (1967/1958), trk# A.04
Gribi, Gerri. Womansong Collection, Gribi, CD (1996), trk# 20 (Hushabye)
Journeymen. New Directions, Capitol T 1951, LP (1963), trk# A.02
Lea, Terrea. Folk Songs & Ballads, HiFiRecord R-404, LP (195?), trk# A.08
Lomax, Alan. Texas Folk Songs, Tradition TLP 1029, LP (1958), trk# 7
Lomax, Alan. Collectors Choice, Tradition 1057, LP (196?), trk# B.03
Odetta. Odetta at Carnegie Hall, Vanguard VRS-9076, LP (1961), trk# B.02
Odetta. To Ella, Silverwolf SWCD 1012, CD (1998), trk# 3e
Raven, Nancy. Lullabies and Other Children's Songs, Pacific Cascade LPL 7007, LP (1969), trk# A.03 (Hushabye)
Robertson, Kim. Tender Shepherd, Gourd GM 112, Cas (1992), trk# B.01
Seeger, Peggy. Three Sisters, Prestige International 13029, LP (1960s), trk# A.08b (Pretty Little Horses)
Seeger, Pete. Seeger, Pete / How to Play the Five String Banjo, Seeger, sof (1962), P49 Seeger, Pete. Seeger, Pete / Goofing-Off Suite, Hargail, Sof (1959), p 8
Seeger, Pete. Asch, Moses (ed.) / 124 Folk Songs as Sung and Recorded on Folkways Reco, Robbins, Fol (1965), p 15
Smith, Peggy Donaldson. Shady Grove, Shady Grove PDS 11-30-78, LP (1978), trk# A.06 

FLOATING LYRICS: Rocky Bye Baby; Go to Sleep/Sleepy Little Baby (Bye); Mama's Gonna Buy;

RELATED TO: Hush-a bye; Black Sheep Where You Leave Yo' Lamb;

OTHER NAMES: "Hush-a-bye"; "Go to Sleepy Little Baby" (Sandburg); "Whole Heap a Little Horses" (Texas Gladden); 

SOURCES: Mudcat forum; Folk Index

NOTES: Odetta said of All the Pretty Little Horses, "A woman crooning a lullaby to a baby while she leaves her own unattended in order to earn money for bread. In the song she refers to her own child as the lambie in the meadow. This lullaby comes from the South, post Civil War."

This lullaby is known from both African-American and white source from the mid-1800's and possibly is older. Below are the lyrics from W. A. Fisher, 1926, Seventy Negro Spirituals, Oliver Ditson Co, Boston, pp. 4-7, with music; Kentucky melody, collection of Miss. M. Crudup Vesey. "...as sung by various black mammys has hushed to sleep five generations of babies in one old Kentucky family." "The melody, in the minor mode, is with lowered seventh."

BLACK SHEEP, WHERE YOU LEFT YOU' LAMB- 1926 version

Black sheep, black sheep, where you left you' lamb,
'Way down in the pasture?
The buzzards an' the flies- A-pickin' out his eyes,
An' the poor li'l lamb say, "Mammy,"
An' the poor li'l lamb say, "Mammy."

Hush-a-bye, don't you cry,
Go to sleep, li'l baby;

The song was printed as early as 1925 by Scarborough and in 1927 by Sandburg. It's been recorded by many people including Peter, Paul and Mary as "Hush-a-Bye." Here's a different list:

Barbara Dickson
Becky Jean Williams
Caroline Herring
Calexico
Charlotte Church
The Chieftains with Patty Griffin
Coil, as "All the Pretty Little Horses", for their album Black Antlers
Current 93, two versions as "All the Pretty Little Horses", for their 1996 album of the same name, one sung by Nick Cave
Esther Ofarim
Friends of Dean Martinez
Grant Campbell For The Burrowers
Holly Cole, as "All the Pretty Little Horses", for her 1997 album Dark Dear Heart
Joan Baez
Judy Collins, for her 1990 album Baby's Bedtime
Kenny Loggins, as "All the Pretty Little Ponies", for his 1994 album Return to Pooh Corner
Laura Gibson, as "All the Pretty Horses", for her EP Six White Horses
Olivia Newton-John
Peter, Paul and Mary, as "Hush-A-Bye", for their 1963 album In the Wind
Shawn Colvin
Shearwater, as "All the Pretty Horses", for their 2004 split album Sham Wedding/Hoax Funeral

Alan Lomax reportedly learned the song from his mother and his version has been recorded and appears on youtube.

The lyrics "birds and butterflies, peck at his eyes" have sometimes been changed to "birds and butterflies, flutter 'round his eyes" to make the lullaby less violent for younger children.  

Notes by John Bealle:

Under various titles—"Go To Sleepy" and "All the Pretty Little Horses" are common—this song is one of the most widely collected lullabies in American folksong. It is a favorite among African American singers and is well know to popular audiences through folksong recordings and collections.

The song employs common functional elements of lullabies, promising pleasant rewards to an infant "when you wake" in order to "lull" the infant to sleep. Moreover, the particular way lullabies solicit the cooperation of the infant is taken as a marker of deeply-held values that shape an individual's self-concept beginning in infancy.

Bess Lomax Hawes (1974) has examined the "when you wake" formula in this song, concluding that on the surface, it seem to contain a bribe, a promise of a reward for good behavior. But on closer examination it is revealed as a simple prediction: "When you wake, you shall have...." This future-orientation distinguishes "Pretty Little Horses" from other American lullabies, which are generally "expressed in present tense and filled with descriptive terms about the surroundings and the activities of various people" (p146).

Other characteristics distinctive for this song involve the spatial isolation of the baby. Most American lullabies situate the sleep-induced baby elsewhere:

"All the people around him in song are actually somewhere else—shaking dreamland trees, gone hunting, out watching sheep, or what have you. Baby, meanwhile, is up in a tree, or sailing off in a boat made out of the moon, or driving away with his "pretty little horses." When he does sleep, he is described as being in a place called "dreamland" which, wherever it is, clearly isn't his own bed; and he is variously requested or ordered to take himself to that "land of Nod" by the linguistic convention that requires English speakers to "go to sleep." Even the most widespread choice of a lulling nonsense syllable takes the form of a spatial metaphor: "bye bye," after all, means both "sleep" and "farewell." (p146)

Hawes believes that in this respect, lullabies form part of the bedrock of American individualism. "If we want independent children," she says, "we must thrust them away from us, and, equally importantly, we must thrust ourselves away from them." As a ritual act, then, lullabies shape the consciousness not so much of the infant as of the caretaker. They are "a mother's conversation with herself about separation" (p148).

But "Pretty Little Horses" does not stress separation. The reason, other researchers have noted, have to do with its connection with African American slavery. In this, the song embodies a cruel irony: slave caretakers comforting the masters' babies with assurances of their material privileges. Scarborough (1925:144-47) observed the song sung specifically for that purpose. The version in Harris's Uncle Remus books begins, "Mammy went away—she tol' me ter stay, an take good keer er the baby" (1892:213-14). And some variants, such as the one that appeared in the Lomaxes' collection, American Ballads and Folksongs (1934:204-5; also in Scarborough 1925:147), contain a mysterious, heartrending stanza, "Way down yonder; In de medder; There's a po' little lambie," which is taken by some to refer to a second baby, a slave baby neglected while the caretaker tends to the master's children (Singer 2001:8). "De bees an' de butterflies; Peckin' out its eyes," the verse continues, "De po' lil thing cried, "Mammy!"

All the Pretty Little Horses- Lomax Arranged Comanche (and Lubbock) Texas May 1939

Mrs. Shirley Lomax Mansell (Mrs. C. C. Mansell) of Lubbock, Texas, made recordings in the home of Judge and Mrs. Oscar Callaway, at the Callaway Ranch, Comanche Co., Texas, of children's songs and lullabies which she learned in her childhood from the singing of her mother, Mrs. Bess Brown Lomax. Mrs. Lomax learned many of these songs from her mother who came to Texas from Virginia. Mrs. Mansell sings these songs to her own two little girls. She is the daughter of John A. Lomax, who made the recordings.

Mrs. Mansell's songs are scattered over several different discs.: 2590, 2591, 2631, 2633, 2636, 2638, 2642, 3796, 3800

Titles: All the pretty little horses
   Go tell Aunt Nancy
   Little kitty (once there was a-) (Long time ago)
   There was a piggy (Tale of a little pig)
   Old woman and the little pig
   I love little willie
   Billy Boy
   I hardly think I will
   Paper of pins
   Crows in the garden
   No, sir, no sir (?)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 ALL THE PRETTY LITTLE HORSES

Shirley Lomax Mansell, who writes the following note, not only speaks for herself here, but for practically every other Southern girl who has ever been rocked to sleep or who has ever sung to her own babies. For "All the Pretty Little Horses" can be found in the repertoire of every southern family, Negro and white; it is the classic of southern lullabies. It is sung in a thousand different ways by as many singers; the "pretty little horses" may be "blacks and bays" or "dapples and greys" but, whatever their color, they have carried almost every southern child off to sleep at one time or another. Here is what Shirley says about the way the song was sung in our family:

All the Pretty Little Horses is a family song. There is not a time when I do not remember it. I am sure it was Grandmother Brown's song; from our mother it now belongs to her four children. Grandmother did not often sing anything but hymns, and those mostly on Sunday afternoons when she rocked back and forth in her little straight, cane-bottomed rocker, alone in her room. Grandmother did not believe that on Sunday people should do anything but attend Sunday School, then church, then read the Bible until time to go to evening services. Her disapproval of our Sunday afternoon walks, when the children from all the neighborhood gathered to explore the woods, or "walk through to the Dam", caused her to shut herself into her room and rock and sing, and I am sure, pray for forgiveness for us all. Her lips would shut into a thin line, and her eyes fill with tears.

But Grandmother Brown loved babies, and she sang to us all, and rocked us, hours and hours, in that same little chair. All the Pretty Little Horses is a wonderful lullaby. The phrases can be changed, a line or two of hums can be put in at will instead of the words, at will, and the baby drifts off into sleep, floating with the little horses the song blends with the squeak of the rocker and the pat of the foot on the rug. The horrible verse about the "bees and the butterflies" was not sung in our house, and should never be used--what baby could sleep with such a pitiful and ghastly picture stamped into his dreamy little soul? I still sing it to my girls when they are ill, but they always request that that verse not be sung. And I don't blame them."

Dorothy Scarborough in her book On the Trail of Negro Folk-Songs says that this is one of the lullabies Negro Mammies sang to their little white charges.

ALL THE PRETTY LITTLE HORSES- Shirley Lomax Mansell 1939
Listen:
http://memory.loc.gov/afc/afcss39/263/2638b1.mp3
Listen: http://memory.loc.gov/afc/afcss39/259/2590b2.mp3

   Hushaby,
   Don't you cry,
   Go to sleepy, little baby,
   When you wake,
   You shall have
   All the pretty little horses--
   Blacks and bays,
   Dapples and grays,
   Coach and six-a little horses.
   Hushaby,
   Don't you cry,
   Go to sleepy, little baby.

   Hushaby,
   Don't you cry,
   Go to sleepy, little baby.
   Way down yonder
   In de medder
   There's a po' lil lambie;
   De bees an' de butterflies
   Peckin' out its eyes,
   De po' lil thing cried, "Mammy:"
   Hushaby,
   Don't you cry,
   Go to sleepy, little baby.